Flexibility vs. Discipline
Pension Freedoms can leave retirees exposed to longevity and purchasing power risks. We believe post-retirement defaults must consist of core components prioritising sustained income, growth and inflation resilience—with disciplined guardrails.
Explore Full PDF
Key takeaways
- Without structured support, retirees often hold excess cash. This behaviour can create a severe drag on returns and erode purchasing power over time.
- Holding 40% or more in equities may improve inflation resilience and longevity risk. High-dividend equities offer a natural solution for inflation and growth.
- Administrators can add simple guardrails, such as capital preservation triggers, to help prevent catastrophic outcomes whilst respecting member autonomy.
Executive Summary
Retirement defaults need income and growth with guardrails
Since their introduction in 2015, Pension Freedoms have offered UK retirees added flexibility. Without support, though, retirees often make decisions that compromise their long-term financial security: holding excessive cash, de-risking too early or withdrawing at unsustainable rates. These systemic issues call for better-designed defaults. We advocate a shift from flexibility‑first to discipline‑first decumulation, an approach consistent with the direction set by the Pension Schemes Bill 2025.
The risks of unconstrained choice
Left unsupported, retirees face three interconnected structural risks:
- Cash drag: holding excessive cash may erode purchasing power. One study estimates retirees who hold one-third of their assets in cash risk a 37% return shortfall over a 20-year horizon.
- Inflation erosion: structural inflation pressures may persist, threatening the purchasing power of conservative portfolios.
- Longevity risk: actuarial data suggests around 25% of 65-year-olds today will live to age 90. Inadequate early-stage capital growth presents a severe risk of depletion in later life.
Designing a guided retirement strategy
To overcome these challenges and capture alpha opportunities, we believe guided retirement frameworks should focus on three core investment pillars:
- Prioritise income generation: Default decumulation solutions should rely on durable, diversified cash flows rather than pure total-return optimisation. A robust model allocates 60–80% to a core income engine of global equities and investment-grade credit, supported by satellite income, an inflation buffer and a minimal cash reserve.
- Ensure inflation resilience: retirement portfolios require structural hedges against inflation. High-dividend equities offer a natural inflation linkage, as mature businesses typically pass cost increases to consumers, which preserves dividend yields in real terms.
- Maintain growth assets: extended retirements demand sustained equity exposure. Our modelling, based on 10,001 stochastic simulations, demonstrates that maintaining an average equity exposure of at least 40% through age 85 significantly minimises the risk of running out of money.
Rules-based guardrails add support
Effective decumulation requires more than advanced asset allocation; it demands precise execution. Master trusts can implement rules-based guardrails to help protect members from behavioural drift whilst maintaining personal autonomy. Key mechanisms include capital preservation triggers to manage sequencing risk, overspending monitors and periodic portfolio rebalancing.
Adopting these sophisticated strategies may help members in their aim for sustainable income, inflation resilience and better outcomes.
All investing involves risks, including the possible loss of principal. There can be no assurance that any investment strategy will be successful. Investments fluctuate with changes in market and economic conditions and in different environments due to numerous factors, some of which may be unpredictable. Each asset class has its own risk and return characteristics.
This material is provided for informational purposes only and is intended for professional/institutional investor and qualified client use only. Not for retail public use.
ALL-03162026-ywpzbq94